100% Free & Public Domain 16,000+ Recipes No Registration Needed

Fish Pie, With Tench And Eels

\"\" 79 \"\"
Recipe Score
Tried & True

Fish Pie, With Tench And Eels

4.5 ✍️ Editor
★★★★★ 5.0 ⭐ Readers (1)
(1 reader reviews)
License
Public Domain
More details
Share:

📝 Description

\"\" 79 \"\"
Recipe Score · Tried & True
⏱ Time
1/2 hour to bake, or rather more if the oven is slow

🥘 Ingredients

2 tench, 2 eels, 2 onions, a faggot of herbs, 4 blades of mace, 3 anchovies, 1 pint of water, pepper and salt to taste, 1 teaspoonful of chopped parsley, the yolks of 6 hard-boiled eggs, puff paste.

👨‍🍳 Method

Clean and bone the tench, skin and bone the eels, and cut them into pieces 2 inches long, and leave the sides of the tench whole. Put the bones into a stewpan with the onions, herbs, mace, anchovies, water, and seasoning, and let them simmer gently for 1 hour. Strain it off, put it to cool, and skim off all the fat. Lay the tench and eels in a pie-dish, and between each layer put seasoning, chopped parsley, and hard-boiled eggs; pour in part of the strained liquor, cover in with puff paste, and bake for 1/2 hour or rather more. The oven should be rather quick, and when done, heat the remainder of the liquor, which pour into the pie.

📜 From Mrs Beeton's Book of Household Management (1861). Public domain.

⭐ Reader Reviews

Honest opinions from readers who have explored this book.

Recipe Score
79
out of 95
✍️ Editor Rating
4.5
Ingredify
⭐ Reader Rating
5.0
1 review
📊 Your Recipe Score
79
0 – 95
⭐ Your Rating
Tap to rate
✍️ Your Thoughts
5.0
Based on 1 reader review
5
1
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0
K
Kira — Modern Adaptor
★★★★★ 2026-05-08
A heritage recipe worth resurrecting

I tried this fish pie, and I must admit, the combination of tench and eels was more intriguing than I expected. I found the eels to be surprisingly tender and mild, a delightful contrast to the firmer tench. The most delightful surprise was the way the mace and anchovies infused the strained liquor with a depth of flavor that was both savory and slightly sweet, a far cry from the bland fish pies I've had in the past. This pie would be a hit with a comfort-seeker looking for a hearty, old-school dish to warm the soul. The puff paste on top adds a lovely crispness that balances the rich, fishy filling. I baked mine for about 40 minutes, and it turned out beautifully golden. The final touch of pouring the heated liquor over the pie before serving added a lovely, comforting warmth. Next time, I might experiment with a modern fish pie base, but this classic method is a keeper.

📄
Download PDF
Print-ready single-page recipe
📝
Download TXT
Plain text version
Ingredify
Browse Ingredify
🍽️ All 5,000+ Recipes 🥣 Soups & Stocks 🍖 Meat & Poultry 🐟 Fish & Seafood 🥗 Vegetables & Sides 🍰 Puddings & Desserts 🍞 Cakes & Breads 🍳 Eggs & Dairy 🥄 Sauces & Dressings 🍸 Drinks & Cordials 🥧 Pies & Tarts 🫙 Jams & Preserves 📜 Misc & Invalid Cookery 📑 All Collections
Ingredify
📑 Collections 📤 Upload Your Book
Account
🔑 Sign In Create Account
Info
About Ingredify